Damp in the basement, a leaking roof or structural problems can seriously complicate a home purchase or construction project. If repairs will cost tens of thousands of euros or the property can only be used in a limited way, buyers and clients commissioning the work face important decisions.
For construction defects in Austria, you may be entitled to repairs, a price reduction, damages or to have the purchase contract unwound. The right approach depends on the contract, the features promised and the extent of the defects.
Existing insurances should also be examined at an early stage; this applies to buyers with legal expenses insurance as well as builders with builder liability insurance and cases in which the liability insurance of a construction company or planner may be affected.
Which building defects justify a claim?
In principle, a property must have those characteristics that have been agreed or can usually be assumed; in addition to the purchase contract, information in the advertisement, the exposé and specific assurances before the conclusion of the contract may also be relevant.
Typical points of contention are moisture and mould, defective waterproofing, leaky roofs and terraces, static problems, significant thermal bridges and errors in construction or refurbishment work.
An older building does not have to correspond in all respects to a new building, but if a comprehensive and professional renovation has been promised, the buyer can rely on it in principle.
This shows OGH 1 Ob 77/23i: The known age of the house had to arouse no doubts about a promised comprehensive and professional renovation.
Guarantee in case of construction defects: Who is responsible?
When buying a house or apartment, warranty claims are generally directed against the seller. Anyone who has commissioned construction or renovation work himself must regularly pursue his contractual claims against the commissioned company.
The general warranty provisions also apply to defective works, so the decisive factor is who has owed which performance and which characteristics.
Warranty generally does not require fault. The seller therefore does not have to have caused or known a defect himself for a warranty claim to exist. Claims for damages, however, require additional conditions.
In the case of significant construction defects, the basis for claims should be clarified at an early stage. Whether improvement, price reduction or reversal is required influences both the further procedure and the necessary proof.
Demanding improvement: Resolving building defects professionally
If you want to keep the property, you will often first require the proper repair of the defects. The law basically provides for a priority of improvement or replacement.
Improvement must be carried out within a reasonable period of time and with the least possible inconvenience; the costs shall be borne by the person responsible for the warranty; a specific description of the deficiencies and a reasonable period of time for remedying the deficiencies shall provide an important basis for enforcement.
High renovation costs do not automatically exclude a claim
In the case of serious structural defects, it is often argued that the renovation is too expensive, but the level of costs is not the only criterion.
In the aforementioned decision 1 Ob 77/23i, the OGH stresses that the importance of correcting the defects for the buyer must be taken into account in particular, including the reduced service life of components, moisture and the threat of further damage.
Especially in the case of problems with the building substance or the usability, it should therefore be carefully checked whether the improvement can actually be refused due to disproportionate costs.
Rewinding the purchase of a house: When is this possible due to construction defects?
Not every buyer wants to wait for an extensive refurbishment or stay permanently in a significantly defective property under certain conditions, the purchase of the house can be reversed.
Not every defect is sufficient; it must not, in principle, be mere minor; in addition, the conditions for the transition from improvement to cancellation of the contract must be met; for example, whether an improvement is impossible or disproportionate, is refused, is not made on time or is unreasonable for reasons recognised by law.
OGH: Reversal despite warranty exclusion
In OGH 3 Ob 238/15v the house had been offered with already completed drainage and insulation of the walls as well as a very good or good condition.
The OGH maintained the assessment that the buyer was entitled to conversion despite a general warranty exclusion.
Anyone who wants to reverse the purchase of a house due to building defects should therefore also secure the original advertisement, the exposé and the correspondence before concluding the contract.
In the case of a reversal, the repayment of the purchase price, the retransfer of the property and the associated financial and land register issues must also be coordinated.
Hidden construction defects despite warranty exclusion
Many real estate purchase agreements contain a warranty exclusion, and its scope must be examined on the basis of the specific agreement.
Between private individuals, a comprehensive waiver of warranty can also record unknown defects, but a general exclusion does not extend to missing promised properties.
Such a case was dealt with OGH 1 Ob 79/23h. After the purchase of the apartment, mold problems resulted from insufficient insulation and a thermal bridge. The OGH did not object to the interpretation that the warranty exclusion associated with the visit only covered recognizable defects on careful visit.
When buying from an entrepreneur by a consumer, there is additional protection: According to § 9 KSchG, warranty rights before knowledge of the defect can in principle not be excluded or restricted.
Price reduction due to building defects: Keeping property and claiming money back
A reversal is not always the desired result, and anyone who wants to keep the house or apartment can demand a price reduction under the appropriate conditions.
Their amount does not automatically correspond to the estimated refurbishment costs. In principle, the so-called relative calculation method is decisive: the value of the defect-free property and that of the defective property are related to the agreed purchase price, for example OGH 5 Ob 52/18k.
In the case of high amounts in dispute, a property valuation may therefore be necessary in addition to a technical assessment and only on this basis can it be assessed whether a proposed payment adequately takes into account the actual disadvantages.
Demand renovation costs: Do builders have to pre-finance themselves?
If the contracting party is responsible for the defect, claims for damages can exist. However, the amount of money required to repair the defects requires that the legal conditions for doing so are met, which may be the case in particular after an improvement has been refused or not made in time.
For owners, then, the financing question often arises: Does an extensive renovation first have to be paid from own reserves?
In OGH 9 Ob 88/16f it was about a purchased residential house with considerable construction deficiencies and static problems due to insufficient foundation.
The OGH confirmed that the beneficiary is not obliged to use his own capital to repair the defects; an advance on the necessary costs, the so-called cover capital, can be demanded for a planned reorganisation; this advance is earmarked and must be used accordingly.
Especially in the case of high renovation costs, such an advance can be economically decisive.
Building defects and legal protection insurance: have legal costs checked
In addition to legal fees and court fees, proceedings concerning significant building deficiencies can also result in high expert costs.
If you have legal protection insurance, your policy should be reviewed at an early stage. In the case of existing coverage, legal fees, court fees, costs of judicial experts and opposing legal costs can be covered to the agreed extent.
However, many contracts contain a client exclusion, which may exempt disputes relating to the design, construction or modification of a building from insurance coverage, for example OGH 7 Ob 41/16d.
Coverage should therefore be checked on the basis of the specific claim and the terms of the insurance, and I will take over the reasoned cover request on request and also check if your legal expenses insurance has already been rejected.
Builders with liability insurance: Claims against you can also be insured
For builders, in addition to enforcing their own claims, it can also be important to defend against third-party claims, such as neighbors claiming damage to their building or third parties claiming to have been injured by the construction project.
A homeowner liability insurance can meet justified claims for damages to the extent insured and defend against unjustified claims. Depending on the contract, corresponding protection can also be included in a home or house and real estate liability insurance.
If claims for damages are made against you as the client, not only your liability, but also the insurance cover should be examined at the same time.
The nature of the construction project, the insured activities, agreed construction cost limits and special exclusions can be decisive, and damage reporting and coordination with the insurer should also be carried out at an early stage.
The client liability is mainly aimed at claims of injured third parties. Building insurance can be relevant for damages to the own construction service depending on the situation. The repair of the own defective construction service is not automatically insured by the client liability.
Construction Company Liability Insurance: What Damage Can Be Covered?
The company liability insurance of a responsible company can also play a role in damages related to construction defects, and a distinction must be made between the defective performance itself and damages going beyond it.
In principle, the costs of properly producing the service originally owed are not automatically covered by company liability insurance, but additional damage to other assets may be insured as consequential damages.
This delineation explains OGH 7 Ob 162/23h The decision also shows that special agreements on costs related to a corrective action can extend insurance coverage.
For builders, this means that repair costs, additional property damage and other disadvantages should be recorded in a technically and legally comprehensible manner, which makes it easier to enforce claims and to check insurance coverage.
What are the deadlines for building defects in Austria?
In the case of immovable property, the statutory warranty period shall in principle be three years from the date of handover; the defect must have already existed at the time of handover and must appear within this period.
For contracts concluded from 1 January 2022, § 933 ABGB provides in principle for an additional limitation period of three months after the expiry of the warranty period. For older contracts and legal defects, special features apply.
A mere letter of formal notice does not interrupt the statute of limitations in principle. Anyone who unsuccessfully requests a restructuring over a longer period of time or waits for an insurance decision should therefore have it checked in good time whether legal action is necessary.
Documenting construction defects and securing evidence
Before extensive refurbishment work, the condition should be carefully documented, in particular photos, videos, handover protocols, existing reports and written communication, and when buying real estate, advertisements and exposés should also be secured.
Depending on the situation, a judicial procedure for the preservation of evidence can be useful and, after a reorganisation, it may be difficult to determine which deficiencies actually existed and which measures were necessary.
Necessary immediate measures to prevent further damage should also be documented and, at the same time, it must be examined whether the contracting party must be given the opportunity to improve.
Lawyer for building defects in Vienna: Targeted enforcement of high standards
Have you discovered significant building defects after buying a home, your construction company refuses to improve it, or are you, as a builder, facing claims for damages and need support from your liability insurance?
As a lawyer in Vienna, I support buyers, owners and builders in enforcing warranty and damage claims, demanding refurbishment costs and reversing defective real estate purchases, as well as examining insurance issues and supporting them in defending claims.
In the case of high values in dispute, the focus is on reliable evidence, the right basis for claims and an economically sensible approach, and I include existing legal protection, client liability and other relevant insurances in this examination.
Please provide me with your purchase contract or construction contract, a brief description of the building defects and existing expert opinions, and if there are insurance companies, please also send me the policies and previous coverage decisions.
Contact me without obligation to check your claims for building defects.
Lawyer David Zellinger
Josefstädter Straße 11/16, 1080 Vienna
E-mail: office@zellinger-law.at
Telephone: +43 670 1992299