Sell-on clauses in football: Can a club claim a share of later sell-on fees?

Football stadium
Later sell-on fees can give rise to additional claims under a football transfer agreement. Have your agreement reviewed.

A sell-on clause in football can still earn a club money after a player has moved several times. This can happen if the original buying club later receives a sell-on fee of its own.

These additional claims can be overlooked when clubs settle their accounts. With large transfer fees, the sums can quickly reach six figures. The wording of the original transfer agreement is decisive.

Your club has submitted a player with a resale share and you can request a review of your claims via my contact form.

What does it mean to claim a share of another sell-on fee?

A sell-on clause entitles a club to part of the proceeds from a later transfer of the player. The payment, also called a sell-on fee, may be calculated on the total transfer proceeds or only on a specified portion of the gain.

A further question arises if the buying club negotiates its own sell-on clause when it transfers the player. If that clause later generates income, the original club may also be entitled to a share.

The first settlement of a resale interest therefore does not necessarily mean that all claims under the clause have been settled.

Example: Club A receives a further EUR 450,000

Club A sells a player to Club B. In the transfer agreement, the clubs agree to a resale share of 10 % in favour of Club A.

Subsequently, Club B sells the player to Club C. From the fixed transfer and eligible conditional transfer payments, Club B achieves a total of EUR 5.000.000, from which Club A initially receives EUR 500.000.

In addition, Club B secures an own resale interest of 15 % vis-à-vis Club C.

Subsequently, Club C sells the player to Club D for EUR 30.000.000, of which Club B receives EUR 4.500.000 due to its sell-on fee.

If the original agreement between Club A and Club B also covers this revenue, Club A is entitled to a further 10 % of EUR 4.500.000, thus EUR 450.000.

In this example, Club A receives a total of EUR 950,000 from the two holdings; anyone who only pays the first resale may miss a further EUR 450,000.

(The example presupposes that the respective clauses fully recognise the said revenues, excluding deductions, caps and other conditions and maturity arrangements.)

Why can the later sell-on fee also be recorded?

Subsequent payment of Club C to Club B is based on the transfer agreement between these two clubs and may therefore form a further component of the consideration for this transfer.

If the original clause in favour of Club A matches Club B’s revenues to a corresponding extent, it can also cover this subsequent inflow.

The claim of Club A is directed against Club B in the scenario shown. A direct payment claim against Club C or Club D does not follow from this.

CAS decision to participate in another sell-on fee

An immediately appropriate decision is CAS 2023/A/9436, FK Apollonia v. KF Laçi, dated 16 February 2024, published in CAS Bulletin 2025/1, pp. 50 et seq.

FK Apollonia had agreed to a 20 % resale shareholding; KF Laçi also secured a 20 % shareholding at the next transfer; after a further change of club, this resulted in an amount of EUR 237,500 for KF Laçi.

Under the original agreement, CAS awarded FK Apollonia 20% of this further revenue, or €47,500. The relevant reasoning is set out in particular at paragraphs 112 and 113.

The decision thus confirms that, under the interpretation of the specific contract, a resale share can also recognise revenue from a further sell-on fee.

Which formulations of contracts are important?

Not every resale clause automatically leads to the same result; in particular, it must be checked which revenues the parties have agreed as a basis for calculation.

Does the clause cover all payments related to the re-transfer, is it limited to a certain fixed transfer, is it related to the whole of the proceeds or to the profit after deduction of certain amounts, or does the contract contain a final settlement or a cap?

Further levels of participation can also be explicitly regulated, for example the transfer agreement set out in CAS 2024/A/10637, SK Slavia Praha v 36 Lion Football Club.

This explicitly provided for a participation in sums received by Slavia from a subsequent transfer from the third club to the fourth club, but the payment dispute there concerned a different question of calculation, and the contractual clause is therefore above all a clear example of the explicit regulation of further levels of participation.

For new transfer contracts, a clear regulation on later sell-on income, billing and information of the eligible association is therefore recommended.

What documents should clubs check?

The starting point is the original transfer agreement, including all supplements, as well as previous billings, proof of payment and correspondence between the clubs.

The additional share also depends on the next transfer contract and the payment entitlements arising from it, for example whether the further sell-on fee is linked to the entire proceeds or only to a surplus proceeds.

Publicly reported transfer fees may give rise to an audit, but they do not replace proof of the contractual basis for calculation, and the information and documents that the original contractual partner must disclose must be assessed separately.

Clubs should therefore also pursue after the first resale whether subsequent transfers can trigger further participation claims.

Enforce resale participation: Austria, FIFA or CAS?

Before a club sues for a resale share, the basis of claims, amount and maturity must be examined, just as important are the relevant deadlines and the jurisdiction.

Whether proceedings are to be brought before an Austrian court, the FIFA Football Tribunal or the CAS depends on the specific case, in particular the clubs involved, the contractual provisions and the applicable procedural provisions.

As a lawyer for sports law and football law, I support clubs in the examination and enforcement of open transfer claims, representing clubs both in national courts in Austria and before the FIFA Football Tribunal and the CAS.

Frequent questions about resale participation

Is there automatically a claim for later sell-on fees?

No, the interpretation of the original resale clause is crucial: participation can be expressly provided for or result from the content of the agreement.

Can a claim exist even though the first sell-on fee has already been paid?

Yes, the payment of the first participation does not necessarily exclude further entitlements, but any settlement agreements must also be examined.

Against which club is the demand?

In the example shown, Club A requires the additional participation of Club B. The basis is the transfer agreement concluded between these two clubs.

Lawyer for resale interests in football

Your club has submitted a player with a resale clause and the then buyer will now receive a sell-on fee himself, and then an examination can result in additional payment claims.

I review your transfer contracts and settlements, calculate possible claims and support your association in their out-of-court and judicial enforcement.

Contact me via the contact form and describe the transfer history and the agreed resale shareholding.

Lawyer David Zellinger
Josefstädter Straße 11/16, 1080 Vienna
E-mail: office@zellinger-law.at
Telephone: +43 670 1992299

WordPress Cookie Plugin by Real Cookie Banner